The Program…
The concept of this program arose from the desire to put some of J.S. Bach’s music in the context of his predecessors, whose music undoubtedly influenced the great master. I chose two genres of pieces: toccatas and suites. While Bach was certainly influenced by the differing styles of Italy, Germany and France of the 17th c. as well as many of his contemporaries, he took these elements and folded them into his own, singular style of composition. I don’t think Bach was particularly concerned about preserving individual national styles or forms in his own works – there are Italian elements in the French Suites, and French elements in the Italian forms, while Bach’s singular mastery of counterpoint is evident virtually everywhere. Therefore, I didn’t program pieces with direct correlations, as in four of the exact same dance forms from each composer. And since there is such variety in the compositions of each of these composers, even within the same genre of pieces, my aim is to show merely a snapshot of each composer to illustrate some of the similarities and differences across time, nationality, and individual style within each genre.
What to listen for…
Generally speaking, a Suite is a collection of stylized versions of typical Baroque dances; some suites also include preludes or other programmatic or character pieces. In France, dance music for the keyboard grew out of the lute repertoire of the early 17th century. While Froberger was German, his education and exposure to different musical styles included a heavy dose of Italianate forms (he studied with Frescobaldi in Rome for a few years) as well as acquaintance with the keyboard and lute styles of France (he also spent time in Paris around the middle of the century). Froberger was one of the first to organize keyboard dances into suites. The order he chose for the dances was consistent: Allemande, Gigue, Courante, Sarabande – not what one might expect considering that later composers, Bach included, chose to put the flashier Gigue as the final movement! Froberger’s compositional style is very unique: personal, rhetorical and extraordinarily expressive. This suite by d’Anglebert was published in France roughly thirty years later than Froberger composed his. While also very expressive, d’Anglebert writes an astonishing profusion of ornamentation which is the epitome of the highly decorated tendencies of French Baroque music. Here I’m including an unmeasured Prelude (an improvisatory piece written without specific rhythms or meter) and a Chaconne. In comparing the suites, we can see many of the trademark characteristics of each dance type present in the music of each composer. The Allemandes are in a moderate duple meter, beginning with a pick-up note, using a mix of melody, style brisé, and a sort of casual counterpoint. (Style brisé refers to the “broken style” used by the French lutenists and later adopted and elaborated by harpsichordists – chords and harmonies are arpeggiated in explicit rhythms to sustain their sound longer on instruments whose tones decay rather quickly.) A general trend to listen for in the Allemandes is the increasing complexity of the counterpoint used and treatment of inner voices. You will also notice, especially in the Allemandes, the French custom of notes inégales: the running 16th notes in d’Anglebert’s Allemande are performed “unequally”, while those in Bach’s are played evenly. The Sarabandes each display frequent emphases on the 2nd beat of the measure. However, the earlier Sarabandes are mostly chordal in their construction, with melody of secondary importance. Bach’s Sarabande is conceived more as melody and accompaniment. In the second section of the Sarabande, Bach introduces some rather Italianate ornamentation to the otherwise French decorations in the form of running triplet 16th notes. The Courantes are all in a lively triple meter – however, while the earlier examples stick with the French manner of shifting the rhythms and accent patterns between 3/2 and 6/4 (this gives them their typical jaunty character), Bach’s version is more akin to the Italian Corrente, with its two contrapuntal voices and stable ¾ meter. The Gigues skip along in their typical compound meter. Both the Froberger and Bach Gigues utilize contrapuntal imitation at the start of each section – but where Froberger uses a melody of four notes to imitate, Bach’s melody is three full measures long and he treats each half of the dance as a mini-fugue, taking the strict use of imitative counterpoint to its extreme. D’Anglebert’s Gigue, on the other hand, doesn’t use contrapuntal imitation but leans into the lilting dance quality – energetic, but not overly fast.
With the Toccatas, there is perhaps a clearer progression. Toccatas are typically characterized by their sectional mix of free, improvisatory styles and imitative, contrapuntal styles. The improvisatory sections of each toccata are flexible rhythmically, while the contrapuntal sections are more metered or regular. The general trend is that the various sections grow in size and complexity from the earlier to the later examples. I’ve chosen to start with one from the undisputed master of early 17th c. Italian keyboard music, Frescobaldi. A keyboard virtuoso on both harpsichord and organ, Frescobaldi wrote his toccatas with elements of learned counterpoint and wild, fantastical, improvisation. While the harmonic language isn’t yet fully tonal, he is daring with his use of chromaticism and dissonant harmonies. Frescobaldi’s contrapuntal sections are quite brief, utilizing short melodies or 4-6 notes as points of imitation, and lasting sometimes only five to six measures. Buxtehude, writing nearer to the end of the 17th c., continues the toccata tradition of mixing improvisatory and contrapuntal passages. Here however, the sections are larger, the harmonies are tonal, the counterpoint is more strictly fugal, and there is a clearer overarching structure. Bach evolves the toccata even further: in addition to the rhetorical improvisatory sections, there is a slow, four-voice motet-like section using imitation as well as two large fugal sections based on the same subject. The second fugue incorporates a countersubject (a second melody which overlays the original subject) and introduces 32nd notes to add to the excitement. One of the most interesting threads one can trace through all three Toccatas is the use of small sections which rely on a sort of “pedal point” – one note will stay constant through several measures while other voices change around this anchor note. This creates a sense of both stasis and repetition, while the voices which are changing create some of the most interesting, and sometimes poignant harmonies. And speaking of harmony, both Bach and Buxtehude use harmonic sequences which are extremely satisfying to the listener. After Buxtehude’s fugue is spent, it morphs directly into repeated harmonic progression similar to Pachelbel’s catchy Canon. Bach built a common progression into his fugue subject itself: the descending circle of fifths (think “I Will Survive”). Because it occurs in every iteration of the fugue subject, we get to indulge in this sonic treat throughout!
– Adam Pearl, 2026

